1. Syesha Mercado -- Nowhere near as good a diva as she thinks she is -- all voice, little heart and soul.
2. Carly Smithson -- See #1. Plus, she reeks of desperation to win. Plus, she scares me -- those big dark eyes and those witchy long nose and chin. I'm so happy she's finally gone.
3. David Archuleta -- Bores me to tears. He's vocally gifted and cute and all. But so is my friend's puppy.
4. Jason Castro -- "Dude!" That's all I have to say.
5. Brooke White -- What she lacks in vocal power she more than makes up for in sincerity, raw emotion and intelligence. False start and bum notes notwithstanding, her quivering "You Must Love Me" was the single truly riveting performance on Showtunes Night when all the other contestants focused on "show" aspect of the theme rather than connecting with the story of their tunes. My third favorite Idol contestant ever (next to Melinda Dollittle and Elliot Yamin). Go for Brooke!
6. David Cook -- The David that should win. And probably would.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment